Karl Franklyn Lehman

Aug 15, 1942 — Nov 9, 2026

Karl F. Lehman, 84, passed away peacefully on November 9, 2026, in Venice, Florida. He was a man of deep faith who loved his family, his friends, and a good conversation.

Karl was born August 15, 1942, in Lewis County, New York, to Addison and Mary (Zehr) Lehman. On August 2, 1964, he married the love of his life, Elaine K. Hartsough, in Elkhart, Indiana. They called Elkhart home for 30 years before retiring to Venice, Florida, where they enjoyed the next chapter of their lives together.

Karl is survived by Elaine, his wife of 62 years, and their three children: Karleia (Rod) Parker of Goshen, Indiana, Regan (Tracei) Lehman of Union, Michigan, and Anjanette (Dan) Prater of Cedar Lake, Indiana. Also surviving are Karl’s brothers, Joe, Chris (Marilyn), Barry (Janet), Chuck (Carol), and his sister-in-law, Marla Lehman. He was preceded in death by his brother, Bob.

He was proud of his 16 grandchildren: Jamin (Georgianne) Parker, Bennett Parker, Derek (Daniela) Parker, Landon Parker, Spencer (Lauren) Lehman, Karlee (Israel) Carr, Emma (Noah) Wright, Sawyer Lehman, Savanna (Brayden) Foshee, Ariana (Branden) Kohnle, Nathan Prater, Alexavier Arce, Avery Arce, Avelina Arce, Danette Prater, and Daxton Prater. He also cherished his two great-grandchildren, Gia Carr and Joanna Wright. All of them brought him tremendous joy.

Karl held his CPA license for more than 60 years; his career took him through industry, teaching, and building businesses. He worked hard to earn an MBA from Columbia University, and he enjoyed being a professor at Goshen College. His proudest professional achievement was founding Lehman & Associates, CPAs, which he led for more than 40 years.

Those who knew Karl will remember him for far more than his work. He lived his faith through generosity and kindness, and he was always ready to engage in conversation, share some wisdom, or offer a word of encouragement. He truly never met a stranger. In business, in friendship, or in a passing conversation, he made people feel welcome and valued.

Karl also knew how to have fun. He loved a good game of euchre, especially when “going alone.” An upstate New Yorker at heart, he was a lifelong Yankees fan, and he loved real New York maple syrup. He frequently kept a spoon in his pocket, so he would never miss a chance at a jar of peanut butter or a bowl of ice cream, and he was never far from a warm cup of coffee.

Above all, Karl loved God, his family, and the many people who became part of his life along the way. His stories, his humor, and his gift for connecting with others will be deeply missed. His legacy and the example he set will live on through the generations that follow.

A Celebration of Life will be held at Waypoint Church, 56893 CR 29, Goshen, Indiana, on Saturday, December 5, 2026. Visitation will be from 2:00 to 4:00 p.m., with a service directly following. All family are invited to stay after the service for a meal.

Flowers may be sent to Yoder Culp Funeral Home, 1911 S. Main St., Goshen, IN 46526.

Guestbook

Visits: 325

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the
Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Service map data © OpenStreetMap contributors